No Room

Luke 2:1-20

Anybody feeling a little crowded this Christmas?

Maybe your calendar is packed with holiday events and year end tasks and lists to buy and do and send and people to see. Maybe your home has been crammed with people, or you have joined the crowd in someone else’s home. Or…perhaps…you had to do some shopping this week?

Crowding – of our personal space, calendars, thoughts and feelings, you name it – is a part of the Christmas festivities, for good or ill, for many of us these days. And it’s a tradition – of sorts – that goes right back to the original Christmas story.

It’s crowded in Bethlehem, isn’t it? All these people, required by the government to travel to their ancestral home: clogging up the roads, trying to find a place to stay, taking up someone else’s space. There’s just no room.

It says so right in the Bible:
And Mary gave birth to her firstborn son, and wrapped him in swaddling clothes, and laid him in a manger, because there was no room for them in the inn.

It’s so crowded that God-made-flesh is exiled to a stable to be born, lonely among the outsiders and the animals.

Or, at least, that’s the way I’ve gotten used to hearing the story.

But there are trends in biblical interpretation just like there are in home design, and this year I kept running into a lot of commentators’ insistence that Jesus was, in fact, born in a house.

Some of these commentaries came with little floor plans of the ancient Palestinian family home, the better to help us imagine how it must have been:
One main room, not that big, but where everything happens: eating, entertainment, work, play, and some sleeping. A manger in a wall or floor of that space because it connects to the animal shelter. And there’s a separate “guest room” – at the back or on the roof – and that’s where there is no room for Mary and Joseph and the baby. 

What happens to the familiar story when you imagine God’s miraculous birth not in a barn separated from it all, but in the middle of a crowded living room/kitchen?

In a house full to bursting with third cousins and multiple times removed relatives all in town for the census, where Jesus is put to sleep in the feed box because there’s simply no other space to lay him down?

This manger story, one commentator said, is all about hospitality, not exile. It’s about the principle that “there’s always room for one more,” even when it’s clear the limits of the space for welcome have been met and even exceeded.

Hm... that’s not the Christmas story I’m used to.

And yet it is.

Because it’s the story told by our secular Christmas celebrations, when we crowd around a table, or on the sofas and side chairs and floor – and still manage to find room for one more, and maybe one more after that.

It’s the story told without words by our pageant earlier this evening, when about thirty busy, excited, active children and youth piled up in that space between the choir that on other Sundays feels crowded when two or three people stand there. Jesus and the Holy Family, shepherds and angels and kings, joyfully on top of one another with not an inch of elbow room to be found.

It’s the story told even in our shopping malls and grocery stores this week, as first choices get scarce and personal space gets scarcer, but the bells ring and the music plays and impetuous generosity and enthusiasm for “one more” takes over from common sense.

That’s a Christmas story where the oddness of the “manger bed” is about taking “always room for one more” to its furthest stretch and beyond.

And while it makes true and perfect sense that Jesus is cradled in an animal’s feed box as a symbol of God’s presence with the poor and downtrodden and the folks who just don’t fit in, it also makes true and perfect sense that God’s birth among us would be all about taking hospitality to its extremes and beyond. After all, for God to make a home among humans at all both demands and expresses the most abundant hospitality we could possibly imagine.

This manger scene is a promise that God comes to us not only when we are alone or make ourselves quiet, but in the most crammed, busy and bursting parts of our lives; that God shows up among us when we have no time, and no space, and no quiet, and demands to be part of it all.

I’ve had an odd experience around here in the last couple of weeks. Moving in December means I’ve had less ability to manage my holiday schedule and tasks than I’m used to. I don’t know the back ways or the short cuts yet, and I’ve gotten stuck in traffic a lot.

And to my great surprise, I have been unusually and surprisingly at peace with these traffic jams. Even when it’s making me late or messing up my plans. 

And more than once – much more than once – I’ve been waved into a lane or through a turn as if the crowding didn’t matter and there was plenty of room for one more.

Now it might just be that I’m new in the area, and this is normal here.

But it might be God.

It might be God being born in the midst of the madness,

God with us who knows what we need when we have no time, no room, to know it ourselves.

After all, being crowded isn’t always joyful. Sometimes it’s miserable. Sometimes it’s excruciatingly lonely.  There are times when hospitality hurts, and you can be exiled right in the middle of it all.

Christmas isn’t only glory; it also encompasses pain and struggle.

And I suspect that that’s another reason God might choose to come in the thick of the crowd, insisting on being present when you’re being overwhelmed.
I suspect that God is born into the rush because we may need healing and grace – may need salvation – in the thick of things more even than when we have space and privacy for our grief or pain.

So, yes, God is at the mall. At the overflowing table. There with both the joyous and the miserable.

And God is just as truly – maybe even more – in overcrowded prisons and homeless shelters. In the jammed refugee buses, shuttling out of Aleppo this month. In a bustling German market suddenly filled with fear. In hearts crowded with pain, and heads crowded with work.

God makes room for Godself out of no room in the midst of grief and evil and strain just as truly as in the delight and familiarity of the contentedly busy kitchen or peacefully packed candlelit church.

And that is a miracle we may need more than we know or guess. Because when we are crowded or cramped; full, busy or overloaded with happiness or pain, we need that miracle of God with us: making holy space where there is no space, sacred time when you have no time, hospitality in a world packed with fear and greed; making room for grace in hearts and souls and calendars too full of anything else to even look for God.

This baby in the manger in a crowded and overflowing house where there is no room, is a promise and a sign for the overflowing challenges of our world and private lives: that where there is most truly no more room, there is space for God, and God will come. That our most cramped and crazy places are where God is made flesh among us, whether we are ready or not, and all you have to do to welcome God is to trust that where there is truly no room, there will be room enough, and let your heart overflow.

-->